Silver's the best
, though the original three I played the most. And there are a lot diff in the game this time around... battles are similar though. And if you think the 3d looks bad, you have clearly not seen it. It looks basically like the others, only better and 3d if it's moving. So, if you hated the way it looked before, you probably won't like seeing it in 3d. The 3d itself though, is well done.
The impression I get is this is what the last Pokemon's should have been, and a bit more (I HATED Ruby and Sapphire).
The starters include a Penguin and a Fire Monkey, which just happen to some of the greatest animals ever. And because of wifi, you'll never have trouble with trading again, and you'll be able to battle anyone you want.
The cards, show, and pretty much everything but the handheld games sucked, as far as I'm concerned.
So yes, this is the biggest, best looking, longest, and most complex Pokemon ever. It may turn out to be repetitive, though most of what was repetitive is taken care of with these versions. I wouldn't have posted so much, but most of the complaints are based on lack of knowledge, so I thought I might post some of what I know (it adds up after checking up every few weeks).