I think David's solution really is the best solution: A ban on IF engines/ editors, but all languages are allowed. The stipulation being that some portion of your entry, albeit in code, graphics, audio, or what-have-you, must have been made using a TGC product. And the inclusion of at least
some small portion of the code, so much as a function (for those who are worried about protecting trade secrets) could guarantee that you didn't just cheat and use an editor. Call me overly faithful, but I think there has to be a level of trust here, and at the end of the day, the bulk of the competition's scoring does revolve around the design and story more than the technological aspects
.
Does this work for everyone? I'm trying to find a median here, and I agree with Rami about this being a TGC competition, as unofficial as it may be, and I'd be lying if I said there wasn't an element of promotion involved, lol. I'll contact Rick and see if we can get some sort of "TGC Stance" on this issue if anyone is still uneasy about it. TGC hasn't gotten involved with the rules before though, its always been a community thing
.
PS.- Last year we had a great panel of judges, and anyone whose been a judge previously is more than invited to email me and let me know you're insterested in doing it again this year
. Anyone else who'd like to be a judge, drop me a line and we can talk about it. I'd love to get a mod to join in this year, wink-wink nudge-nudge
. I won't be available via messenger from June 2nd to June 16th but I'll still be around, just email me and I'll get back to you as soon as possible. I'd like to get the judges sorted in the next week or two if I can.