Quite obviously you are annoyed you didn't win. So what if it only took a few minutes, like said before, the artifacts are there due to the very small file size limit, at the time I couldn't get the file size down.
The banner won because it was funny. People obviously liked it because they voted for it.
I suggest you do some thinking and grow up. I don't see why you are so cut up about it. The only reason I can see is that you are a very sore looser.
To be quite honest with you, If the idea was so blatantly obvious and easy... Why didn't you come up with it? If you are such an artistic genius?
My
winning entry for the Christmas card competition didn't uphold the same visual quality of an ILM render, it was basic. But it was amusing. This is why it won and this is why my banner won.
The sooner you realise that the competition wasn't fixed and that the banner won due to its charm, the better it will be for everybody.
I'm sorry for throwing your thread off the rails Mr Tank. Its just that I don't tolerate somebody ridiculing myself or my work over the fact they can't stand to loose.