Both teams were really weak.
England were just a total shambles - some really nice crosses / chances that just failed to 'come together' as well as some really atrocious playing from 'star' players (Gerrard constantly giving the ball away, Lampard being wholly useless as always)
USA seemed slightly more organised - when they had the ball they made use of it (England just seemed to waste time passing it back and forth) but they seemed to lack the attacking strength / crosses (as evidenced by the many shots on target done from a distance rather than close to goal)
In short, two weak/mediocre teams that will certainly be obliterated by a stronger team (Either of them vs. Brazil, Portugal, Mexico, Netherlands etc. = bye bye World Cup)
Quote: "U.S. beating England at their own game."
Whilst both teams sucked, this is not a win for either side. A draw isn't a win. Especially when your only goal comes from a goalie fumble (it was a nice shot on target but you can't really say it was the USA's strength that secured them the game for them.)
EDIT:
Also, that GIF is pretty rubbish - the camera shot completely misses the part where he is actually holding the ball and then drops it (which is why it's such a humiliating goal for him)
09-f9-11-02-9d-74-e3-5b-d8-41-56-c5-63-56-88-c0