Wrong coordinates returned from GetSpriteContactWorldX/Y ??

Author

Message

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 21st Nov 2012 18:36

Link

I'm trying to get physics contact point from just one sprite and these point seems to be wrong at some times.. my sprite just floats and sometimes hits map sprites so I can see clearly where contact should be. Now it seems to give me contacts that were true earlier.

I place particle emitter to contact point to get some nice sparks but now sparks appear in wrong places..

(contains some debugging lines..

+ Code Snippet

    if GetParticlesMaxReached( 2 )=1 AND GetSpriteFirstContact( mySprite )  = 1
        //Print( "contact!!!")
          contX# =  GetSpriteContactWorldX()
          contY# =  GetSpriteContactWorldY()
          SetParticlesPosition( 2, contX# ,  contY# )
          //GetSpriteContactWorldX( )
            ResetParticleCount(2)
          //SetParticlesActive( 2, 1 )

          //for contNum = 0 to 40
          //  if GetSpriteNextContact()=0 then exit
          //next
    endif

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 25th Nov 2012 18:32

Link

Did you set physics for all of the sprites involved?

(Also, what version are you using: v1076, v1082, v1083)

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 25th Nov 2012 19:26

Link

Yes I did and I tried both v1076 and v1083 beta. Same result on both and I tried polygonal and square collision shapes, same result.

From attached image you can see how strange collision point can be..

Attachments

Login to view attachments

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 25th Nov 2012 19:30

Link

This was bit wrong: " Now it seems to give me contacts that were true earlier. " This does not seems to be case, it just almost randomly picks coordinates that are not near contact area, looks bit like x/y/or both coordinates jump around the sprites origin..

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 26th Nov 2012 16:06

Link

I can't see what's wrong in the image you posted.

The physics box for the ship is in contact as it should be in both images, based on it's shape (a box).

The 'not ok' image has three contacts and the 'ok' image has two.

How is the 'not ok' image not okay?

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 26th Nov 2012 16:38

Link

Sorry, I forgot to write that there is that yellow point sprite in picture that shows GetSpriteContactWorldX and Y coordinate (first one), in "not ok" picture contact point is far away from actual contact/collision points.

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 26th Nov 2012 19:05

Link

Okay, that does make a difference.

Have you tried taking "GetParticlesMaxReached( 2 )=1 AND" out of the if statement and see what happens?

I don't know if the AppGameKit engine caches contacts and is reporting something that happened earlier.

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 26th Nov 2012 19:43

Link

I did try that and few other trick that could make difference, like getting that second sprite that was collided (GetSpriteContactSpriteID2) and then checking that sprite contact x/y coordinates.. but same result.

+ Code Snippet

    if GetSpriteFirstContact( mySprite )  = 1
             temp2 = GetSpriteContactSpriteID2() 
            Print( "contact with a sprite: " + str(temp2))
            if GetSpriteFirstContact( temp2)= 1

                contX# =  GetSpriteContactWorldX()
                contY# =  GetSpriteContactWorldY()

                contX2# =  GetSpriteXbyoffset(temp2)
                contY2# =  GetSpriteYbyoffset(temp2)

                SetSpritePositionbyoffset ( dummy, contX#, contY# ) // contact point
                SetSpritePositionbyoffset ( dummy2, contX2#, contY2# ) // collided sprite position
            endif

    endif

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 28th Nov 2012 16:05

Link

How about doing a loop that collects all contacts after the first one and just ignore them:

+ Code Snippet

if GetSpriteFirstContact( mySprite )  = 1
  // get the first contact
  temp2 = GetSpriteContactSpriteID2()
  Print( "contact with a sprite: " + str(temp2))

  // get the contact coordinates
  contX# =  GetSpriteContactWorldX()
  contY# =  GetSpriteContactWorldY()

  // cycle and clear the contact list
  while GetSpriteNextContact() = 1
    x = GetSpriteContactSpriteID2()
  endwhile

  // set the position of your dummy
  SetSpritePositionbyoffset ( dummy, contX#, contY# ) // contact point
endif

This is based more on your first code snippet than your last.

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 28th Nov 2012 17:54

Link

Same result with that code.. I tried polygonal and box shapes, they gave similar contact placing errors but circle shape somehow gave circle center as contact point!! Even more odd..

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 28th Nov 2012 18:18

Link

Can you show some of the code for how you are creating the sprites?

It is sort of hard to debug with limited information.

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 29th Nov 2012 07:37 Edited at: 29th Nov 2012 17:51

Link

I'm at work now so I tried to make little collision test with trial AppGameKit (might behave differently than norman AGK).. it is different than code I use but I hope it shows something. Use mouse to "guide" one sprite collide other in different angles/sides. Small rectangle shows collision point and very small one is just for mousejoint.

SetVirtualResolution ( 320, 480 )

LoadImage ( 1, "small_blue.png" )

CreateSprite ( 2, 1 )
CreateSprite ( 3, 1 )

CreateSprite ( 6, 1 )
CreateSprite ( 7, 1 )

SetSpritePosition ( 2, 100, 0 )
SetSpriteAngle(2,40)
SetSpritePosition ( 3, 140, 200 )
SetSpriteAngle(3,-10)

SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
SetSpriteScale(6,0.2, 0.2)
SetSpriteScale(7,0.1, 0.1)

SetSpritePhysicsOn ( 2, 2 )
SetSpritePhysicsOn ( 3, 1 )
SetSpriteShape( 2, 3 )
SetSpritePhysicsCanRotate( 2, 0 )

CreateMouseJoint( 1, 2, 100+GetSpriteWidth( 2 )/2 , 0+GetSpriteHeight(2)/2 , 40000 )

SetPhysicsDebugOn()

do

if GetPointerState()=1
        SetJointMouseTarget( 1, GetPointerX() , GetPointerY()  )
        SetSpritePosition ( 7, GetPointerX()-3, GetPointerY()-3 )
    endif

if GetSpriteFirstContact(2)=1
        spr2 = GetSpriteContactSpriteID2()
        tx# = GetSpriteContactWorldX( )-6
        ty# = GetSpriteContactWorldY( )-6
        SetSpritePosition ( 6, tx#, ty# )
        print("collision with sprite:" + str(spr2))
    else
         SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
    endif

//    if GetFirstContact()=1
//        spr1 = GetContactSpriteID1()
//        tx# = GetContactWorldX( )
//        ty# = GetContactWorldY( )
 //       SetSpritePosition ( 6, tx#, ty# )
  //      print("collision with sprite:" + str(spr1))
  //  else
  //       SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
  //  endif

Sync ( )
loop

+ Code Snippet


SetVirtualResolution ( 320, 480 )

LoadImage ( 1, "small_blue.png" )

CreateSprite ( 2, 1 )
CreateSprite ( 3, 1 )

CreateSprite ( 6, 1 )
CreateSprite ( 7, 1 )

SetSpritePosition ( 2, 100, 0 )
SetSpriteAngle(2,40)
SetSpritePosition ( 3, 140, 200 )
SetSpriteAngle(3,-10)

SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
SetSpriteScale(6,0.2, 0.2)
SetSpriteScale(7,0.1, 0.1)

SetSpritePhysicsOn ( 2, 2 )
SetSpritePhysicsOn ( 3, 1 )
SetSpriteShape( 2, 3 )
SetSpritePhysicsCanRotate( 2, 0 )

CreateMouseJoint( 1, 2, 100+GetSpriteWidth( 2 )/2 , 0+GetSpriteHeight(2)/2 , 40000 )

SetPhysicsDebugOn()

do


    if GetPointerState()=1
        SetJointMouseTarget( 1, GetPointerX() , GetPointerY()  )
        SetSpritePosition ( 7, GetPointerX()-3, GetPointerY()-3 )
    endif


    if GetSpriteFirstContact(2)=1
        spr2 = GetSpriteContactSpriteID2()
        tx# = GetSpriteContactWorldX( )-6
        ty# = GetSpriteContactWorldY( )-6
        SetSpritePosition ( 6, tx#, ty# )
        print("collision with sprite:" + str(spr2))
    else
         SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
    endif


//    if GetFirstContact()=1
//        spr1 = GetContactSpriteID1()
//        tx# = GetContactWorldX( )
//        ty# = GetContactWorldY( )
 //       SetSpritePosition ( 6, tx#, ty# )
  //      print("collision with sprite:" + str(spr1))
  //  else
  //       SetSpritePosition ( 6, -20, -20 )
  //  endif


    Sync ( )
loop

edit: typo fixed "GetSpriteContactWorldX()" -> Y

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 29th Nov 2012 15:48

Link

I'll give it a test in v1076 and v1083 if you'll load the image file referenced (or tell me the shape/size of it).

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Jogimus

11

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 10th Nov 2012

Location:

Posted: 29th Nov 2012 17:45

Link

It is a 50*50 square sprite image from "Physics-StaticAndDynamic" example.

Back to top

Profile PM

Ancient Lady

Valued Member

20

Years of Service

User Offline

Joined: 17th Mar 2004

Location: Anchorage, Alaska, USA

Posted: 29th Nov 2012 18:16

Link

Okay, tested in v1076.

Strange behavior indeed.

If the contact point is between a flat edge on the moving sprite and a corner on the non-moving one, the reported/displayed contact is in the correct place.

If it is between a corner on the moving and a flat on the non-moving, it reports the contact on the corner of the non-moving one that corresponds to the corner on the moving one that actually made contact.

If I use a round image and set the shape on sprite 3 to circle, the 'reported' contact point is always the center of sprite 3.

If I make sprite 2 a circle and sprite 3 a box, the contact point is always in the center of sprite 2.

Setting both to square and box, and we are back to wierd reporting.

The behavior persists in v1083 and v1084.

This is officially a bug.

I'll report/confirm it in the official bug lists.

Cheers,
Ancient Lady
AGK Community Tester

Back to top

Profile PM

Sorry your browser is not supported!

AppGameKit Classic Chat / Wrong coordinates returned from GetSpriteContactWorldX/Y ??

Attachments