Toaster gun for the win. What was firing the bullets over the top of the rolling pin? Was that an icing squeezy bag thing?
I like the shaders too - don't care if they look slimey or anything. It adds to the character, imo. But I do second the menu looking a bit bad. The idea is great with the notes, pin and handwriting etc. but it seems to lack the polish of the rest. Specifically, the border of the pin board is ropey, and it'd be nice if the whole pinboard was on a wall, rather that surrounded by black. Otherwise, it all looks good.