Quote: "Zelda would not make a good movie. The storyline is not nearly as rich as other fantasy-based novels like LOTR. I just can't see this being a good idea, ever. Look at the SMB movie for your proof."
Most books are too long to be made into movies, look at Harry Potter (if you've read the books) where the books are massive but most doesn't make it into the movies. The story in Zelda is excellent for a movie and this definitely looks way better then movies like Eragon and that horrible one with a boy looking for symbols.
SMB is a bad example as the movie itself barely have anything to do with the games. There's an animated Zelda series BTW, not seen anything but trailers myself though.
[center]