The first song I completed in GH on Expert was "I Love Rock and Roll", about um... 2 years ago
Usually the GH threads (most of which are started by me) is about 5-staring one of the hardest songs on Expert, not completing them (unless it's Jordan or TTFAF). IIRC last song I 5-stared was Gemini on GH2 and next up will be either Psychobilly Freakout GH2 or Cought in a Mosh 80s (very close on both). But I'm not playing much these days.
The song I'm most glad I completed was Bark at the Moon on Expert in GH1 and unlocked the Battle Axe a week before the release of GH2. It's almost impossible to HOPO in GH1 so it's a challenge. I have yet to complete Jordan which will most likely top that experience.
[center]