I just played the demo twice and here is my review (in my usual TGTBATU format):
The Good:
- overall atmosphere. Its a fantasy game that looks and feels like fantasy, not just like a "zombie game with a sword". The rats eveywhere in the cellar where a nice touch.
- level building. Good work, especially the cave looks like everything one is supposed to do with Cosmic Prophets cave pack. And(spoiler)
the climbable wall was a nice addition.
The Bad:
- (spoiler)
The first enemy is attacking through the doorframe AND he can be hit only in crouch
. The enemies are impossible to kill until you get a missile weapon but dont pose much of a threat afterwards.
The Ugly (sorry its so much):
- Music.The starting music sounds like an old castlevania tune and the end music is 100% original Oblivion. This really spoils the very athmospheric ingame music
- The "Duke Nukem" loading screen.
- Lighting (cellar only)It seems to switch suddenly on and off in the cellar so you see perfectly well in the segment you just stand in but it looks pitch black everywhere else (the lighting in the cave is superb though).
- ending a level with a crossbow and starting the next one with a longbow is kinda weird.
Overall I am looking very much forward to see more of your game
In case you find my grammar and spelling weird ---> native German speaker ^^