Dunno if this belongs in game design or general, but I guess it will get more views in general and im really hoping for alot of responses.
Some of you may of seen the RPG hybrid I have been working on lately. My original intent has been to cast the lead roll to a female character, Bella.
Now I was just flaunting off some early concept art of her to a friend (sorry, too early for these forums
) and the first thing he said was "your casting the lead as a girl?"
I said yup. He says isnt that a little unusual for the genre? I said yes, exactally. I see no reason why zelda cant go save link now and then. From there we started up a big discussion. His primary worry was that the RPG audiance is largely male and the main attraction to the genre is the huge bond you end up devloping with your avatar (the character).
I countered with I could see no problem, the guys should be happy due to the.. um, pleasent sight infront of them and the girls should be happy that their gender got the lead roll rather than the "oh! please save me! *BOSSOM SHAKE*" side role which are generally there just to give the main guy something to do. My friend had no problem with any of that, but worried that
"But the stories tend to be very oriented towards blokes; damsels-in-distress, coming of age, gangs and territory etc.
So what you have in an RPG is a male player adopting a male avatar and playing through a story aimed, broadly, at males. I don't know how well that would work with a girl avatar.
"
I countered again refrancing the simularity between rpgs and books and how immersive books can be and listed various ones i got deeply engrossed in with female leads. Also pointed out the attraction of the bond you devlop with the character, the care about them, their plight and their goals and the desire to see these through to success etc. After a few moments thought he said:
"Hmm. As I think more about it, I think it matters less. It's worked just fine in other genres, after all."
But it did leave me wondering. I had won him over, but will this be the intial reaction of all my other potential players who I wont be there to reason with? This is where you guys come in - your opinion and a simple vote please.
I would like you to say either "I would be happy with a female lead" or "I would prefer a male lead in an rpg" and, if its ok, please state wether you are male or female as I think that its important for me to try and get a grasp on the opinions of both genders here. I had hoped these forums had a poll thing like lots of others so i could give im male/female in the vote options and retain your annominity.. but i cant, so if you DONT want to disclose your sex please state that you dont want to say.
Thanks, this should turn out interesting.
[07:16:59-pm] « Sephnroth » you were dreaming about lee...
[07:17:13-pm] « Mouse » stfu
[07:17:22-pm] « Mouse » he was hanging himself lol