Quote: "They'd get banned, I guess."
But without the slap count the problem wouldn't be there in the first place.
If people get slapped because they've done something wrong they learn from it and improve, they might want to start afresh and not be reminded about what they used to do.
If they continued being a prat then they would get slapped again and eventually banned.
I see no reason for knowing how many times someone has been slapped.
Quote: "That way newbs would be publicly scarred"
But then they wouldn't be able to improve without some people judging them because they can see what has happened in the past.
I don't want to start an arguement but in my opinion there is almost zero reason for having a slap count.
*tries to think of witty and original signature*
*fails*