You guys are acting like you have a fundamental right to the Internet--- guess what, you don't. The companies that actually laid the wires and pipes into the ground--- hundreds of thousands of miles, think they should get a bigger piece of huge site's revenue (Google, Microsoft, Amazon, etc.). To play the devil's advocate, why should Google be getting what is a "free" ride?
And like that guy in the video said (Timothy Wu I think his name is)-- is that if you were the gatekeeper to the Internet, why *wouldn't* you want to do this?
And Phaelax--- you try making your own private Internet when AT&T, etc. actually physically own the cables you use to send data. What, you're going to lay your own wire across America?