Here's my crit. All of them were excellent so I will go through them all.
Disturbing13, loved your game. It lagged a bit but that's probably just my computer. I liked the custom weapons and I found the sniper rifle. The enemy characters were good and the giant monster scared the crap out of me. For some reason I couldn't complete the game. I thought it was very clever, the way you had to walk across the edges of the walls to get the sniper rifle. All in all it was a very good game.
Candle, the custom media made the game look good but it was just too short to really enjoy. I killed all those erm, things but as soon as I killed the last one the game ended. If it was just a bit longer then I would of enjoyed it.
Higgins, this game was brilliant. I played it more than once, thats for sure. The redneck, american theme suited the game well, an I liked the players constant remarks "whats that there smell?". Great voice acting. The enemies made me jump quite a bit sometimes, and I liked puching them. The level was well designed and you made good use of custom media. My brother played it as well and he thought it was better then the others.
If I was judging by myself I would of given these places (without favouring anyone in particular.
1st Place: Higgins
2nd Place: Disturbing13
3rd Place: Candle
But of course that is my personal opinion.