Ok, I thought both of those vids were quite cool. The guy doing the impressions was pretty good, although I find impressions a bit boring, but worthy of a YouTube slot. The dating one was quite funny and true and I watched that one to the end.
I think they're both good enough to watch, but eh, the 1st guy has got a talent and the 2nd guy was actually pretty witty and had a good subject we can all relate to (well most of us) to talk about. My concern would be, if you got 20 people from this forum, maybe 1 of them, if you're lucky, will have the witt and subject matter to make a talking/blog type video on par with those ones.
I reckon you should give it a go tho. I mean, personally I wont judge you harshly, cos it's hard to sit down with the intention of making an amusing video. Most of us will have had our moments and put a bunch of people in hysterics as you rant about something, and if a camera man was about at the time you would have some gold material, but when it's contrived it's normally sh*t. So, I'd just say if a bunch of people gave this idea a go, I wouldn't really expect any quality.
Like I said though, it's probably worth a try. If you dont try, you wont find out. Maybe you'll be able to put together a good game rant, or maybe someone else will have to get something off their chests and contribute a vid. If I really feel like I need to rant on something, I might have a go and film myself and see how retarded I look. If I think it's not complete sh*te, I might post it up, but no promises. Nothing looks worse than someone who films themselves talking about something thinking their the mutts and actually everyone who's watching thinks they're lame. That's a death sentence in social respect.
So, good idea, but hard to make it anything other than 5 people who know each other vaguely from the internet and are chatting about boring sh*t. That's the challenge. Good content. If you got something you think is worth hearing about for some peeps, give it a try man.