Personally I think WoW is an exercise in very very clever game design. I cannot really explain it, but there is something utterly captivating about the whole thing. It's just hard enough to be a challenge, while easy enough to keep on progressing, while rewarding enough to make you want to actually progress.
The first 30 or so levels for the newcomer are a real revelation. Game design beauty. Beyond that things start to get a bit more mundane (kill X to get Y, kill X until they drop X, take X to Y, etc) but by this stage you'll be on the battle grounds, probably in a guild, definitely into a profession or two (engineering, oh yeah!), and capable of roaming most of the lands without worrying about getting slammed instantly.
I love the graphical style. The attention to detail is insane, and the effects are just lovely. I'm not the only TGCer to WoW either - Ravey is a total hardcore WoW freak, as is Mike only less so (it was he who got me into it!). I don't have bags of free time (an 8 month old son and a busy job will do that to you), but I do love to just pop in and play for a few hours now and again. Mind you, the Wii is taking most of my gaming time up now
Ahh.. Super Castlevania! Retro bliss.
Heavy on the Magick