Quote: "I never said it was the second best i just hardly doubt RS is the second best, its just more of the known ones, alot of indie MMOs from asia are very popular"
no, RS is the second most popular excluding guild wars, per membership subscription. That's a fact, not an opinion, and you seem to have a whole lot of trouble understanding that. I'm talking about numbers, not peoples opinions. The Asian model is hard to gauge by, as most of the people playing don't buy the pay for items, or buy so few that there is not enough profit to match the subscription model. The only way to compare them to RS is if you include the free players in RS, which means it still vastly outnumbers them. This also eliminates other free MMos, as I'm almost certain RS is the most popular free MMO. I'm unsure how popular Maple Story is, but I believe RS is more popular. I mean, how more accessible can you get than a browser based game? The requirements for playing RS are so low nearly any computer in use can handle it.
Quote: "Guild wars takes a diffrent tactic than most popular MMOs today...im not saying its the best im just saying its good in my taste"
I honestly could care less what anyone thinks the best is in this case. Again, you really need to learn the difference between opinion and fact. Anyone could say anything is the best, and no matter what it's an opinion. I could rather count the amount of people playing a certain game though, and tell you which is the most popular, because of the number of people playing. RS could be considered the most popular if you counted free accounts I believe, but if you only count memberships, it's second next to WOW, or third if you count Guild Wars.
And so you know, I've read the entire Guild Wars website, many reviews, and have seen a number of friends play it. I'm even following information about Guild Wars 2. You really can't tell me much factual information about it that I don't know. I'll also be trying a trial that came with a friends copy fairly soon.
Quote: "At least with Runescape, you're capable of doing different things, exploring bigger places (if you're a member) and the quests can entail new things and different types of things. There aren't 3 types of quests, (collecting, killing, finding) a lot of them come with a story to follow and can be more engaging and the towns are more 'local' with things that make the town special. I mean one town in the free world is well suited for miners, another for craftsman and so on."
You've nailed exactly why I like RS. I basically became a member the day I completed all of the quests in free player.